ARTICLE

New Leader, New Role: Why Doing the Work Yourself Is Holding You Back

by Shanda K. Miller

Chris was the most productive accountant at her firm. So when the team leader retired, her boss Mary promoted her. Chris was thrilled. She promised to keep the division the best in the firm.

Then she got to work. Chris wanted to be sure the team performed at its best. She noticed everyone used a different format for client reports, so she set a new standard.

She also asked staff to send every report to her for review first. If she had more control, she thought, she could guarantee quality.

How One Good Intention Went Sideways

Soon Chris's days filled up. Staff stopped by with questions about the new format. One asked her to check a report. Chris spotted a few changes and thought, "It's just as fast if I make these myself."

So she did. She emailed back the finished report.

That became the pattern. Chris was reviewing and editing reports, preparing her own client reports, and fielding interruptions. She came in earlier and left later. She missed her family.

Then a client called asking where his report was. The accountant was out sick. Chris spent the whole day finishing it herself.

The Day Phil Walked In

A month after her promotion, Chris sat down with the division's performance numbers. Every category was below expectations. Client satisfaction had slipped too.

The next morning, Phil asked to talk. He had transferred in from another division, and now he wanted to transfer back.

"I've been unhappy here," he said. "And it's not just me. The team doesn't feel trusted or supported."

Chris went to Mary with her head down. "I performed well as a staff accountant," she said. "But I'm not prepared to be a team leader."

Does this sound familiar? Being a team leader is a different role from being a staff member. It takes different skills.

Why We Default to Doing the Work

Here's what happened to Chris. When we lack team leadership skills, we fall back on what we know best. We do the work ourselves. Or we insist the work be done the way we would do it.

Another word for that is micromanaging. It rarely feels like micromanaging from the inside. It feels like caring about quality.

But your team feels it differently. Most employees run as fast as they can from micromanagers. I did.

Early in my career, I worked for a nonprofit with a cause I was passionate about. After six months, I realized my boss was a micromanager. I had let that dampen my passion. So I looked for a new job.

What Micromanagement Does to Your Team

You can have skilled, competent people. Give them a micromanager, and they'll become disengaged and unhappy. Here's what it can do to them:

  • Fear of disappointing you

  • Low self-confidence

  • Reduced productivity

  • Less creativity

  • Lack of motivation

  • Increased absenteeism

  • Resentment

That's a steep price for control. And as Chris found, the control didn't even deliver the quality she wanted.

So What Do You Do Instead?

Knowing what not to do is only half of it. The other half is knowing what your job actually is.

Your most important role is to define the team's objectives and guide the team toward them. Another key role is to grow and develop each team member. Everything else supports those two.

Think of your new job as a set of roles, not a task list. Here are the eight roles I describe in From Supervisor to Super Leader:

  • Engage and inspire your team around a shared purpose

  • Create a road map for reaching your objectives

  • Be the project manager when your work is project-based

  • Delegate the work

  • Develop staff

  • Be the coach

  • Connect and communicate with your team and with management

  • Facilitate team building and open-minded discussions

Start With Delegation

Delegation is where many new leaders struggle most. The key is to assign large chunks of work, not individual tasks.

For example, give someone an entire section of a report. Include the research and everything else needed to write it. People can still collaborate with teammates. But the assignment is theirs.

That gives them ownership, and ownership drives engagement. It also frees you to do the work only you can do.

Then make sure the outcome is clear. Spell out your expectations for quality and your deadline. If your team member has questions about how to do the work, offer coaching, training, or extra support.

Ask Yourself One Question

When you catch yourself reaching to fix someone's work, pause. Ask yourself, "Is this my job, or am I falling back on my old one?"

Sometimes the answer is that coaching would serve them better than a quick fix. They learn, and you get your time back.

Here are a few ways to start this week:

  • List your current tasks and circle the ones a team member could own.

  • Delegate one big chunk of work, with clear expectations and a deadline.

  • Hold back from editing the next time you're tempted. Ask a coaching question instead.

  • Review the eight roles and pick one you haven't been practicing.

You Can Do This

Chris didn't fail. She was promoted for being great at one job and handed a different one without a guide. That's common.

What matters is what she did next. She went to her boss and asked, "Can we talk about my role and what I need to do to be successful?"

You can ask that question too. Your skills got you here. A new set of skills will take you further.

Heads up: This post is adapted from my book From Supervisor to Super Leader with the help of AI, but thoroughly reviewed and edited by me.

What’s one thing you could hand off this week?

Get Shanda's bestselling book

Improve your team skills now. Do you want to be better at coaching staff? Do you find it hard to give honest feedback? Get this book.

Helping leaders thrive!

© 2026 Become a Super Leader - All Rights Reserved

1711 Willamette St Suite 301 #739

Eugene OR 97401