ARTICLE

Why Your Team Doesn't Trust You Yet (And How to Fix It)

by Shanda K. Miller

Ann started her meat pie business with a food cart and one employee. Her pies got popular. Soon she sold them at local restaurants, grocery stores, and special events. Before long she had four employees.

One of them was Mark. Ann hired him on the spot to fill orders and deliver them around town. Mark was out making deliveries most of the time, so Ann rarely saw him. She never made time to get to know him.

A month later, Ann noticed a problem. Some of Mark's order receipts were illegible or missing customer signatures.

The Conversation Ann Dreaded

As Ann prepared to give Mark feedback, she realized something. She didn't really know him. She felt nervous and uncomfortable about approaching him. She figured it wouldn't be a comfortable conversation for Mark either.

So Ann thought, "It's well past time I made an effort to get to know Mark." She took him out to lunch a couple of days later.

Ann's instinct was right. But imagine if she had started the relationship on day one. That feedback conversation would have been far easier.

Relationships Are the Foundation

Stephen Covey wrote, "When the trust account is high, communication is easy, instant, and effective." That sentence explains Ann's problem. She had nothing in the account when she needed to make a withdrawal.

The quality of our relationships is the foundation for everything we do as leaders. We interact with team members, managers, and clients every day. When we invest in those relationships, we communicate, work, and learn together better.

The key is to be intentional. Make relationship building one of your top priorities.

Stage 1: Build the Relationship

Trust doesn't happen overnight. Think of each relationship as a long-term investment. When you first work with someone new, meet with them one-on-one at least once a week.

The best way to get to know someone is to ask for their life story. Ask where they were born and raised. Ask about meaningful events or milestones. Be curious. Listen and ask open-ended questions.

Then share your own story. It has to go both ways.

In the early weeks, also learn each person's strengths and aspirations. Ask what their goals are and where they want to be in five years. While they share, suspend judgment, show empathy, and focus on listening.

Be Open About Yourself

If you've done the self-knowledge work, share it. Tell your team about your blind spots, your limiting belief, your strengths, and the areas you're working to improve. Share your leadership purpose too.

Yes, this takes vulnerability. That's the point. When you're open and honest, you create space for others to be open with you.

Stage 2: Strengthen the Relationship

Once trust is growing, you can meet less often. Weekly can become twice a month or monthly.

At this point, ask for feedback. Ask each person how they think you're doing as their leader. Then show you can take it. Listen, ask follow-up questions, and don't get defensive.

When your team sees you receive feedback well, they trust you enough to keep giving it. Douglas Stone and Sheila Heen put it this way: "People who are willing to look at themselves are just easier to work with and to live with."

It also creates room for them to ask you for feedback in return.

Stage 3: Maintain It

Once the relationship is strong, keep it strong. Meet one-on-one at least once a month.

Over time, you'll have greater confidence in the relationship and deeper trust. You'll be able to rely on each other and make requests of each other. The relationship becomes energizing for both of you.

The Small Daily Habit

Between meetings, go out of your way to acknowledge each person every day. Greet them by name and ask how they're doing. Ask about their life outside of work.

A peer of mine greets his staff every morning and asks how they're doing. One of his team members told me everyone appreciates that daily gesture. Julie Morgenstern said it well: "How we treasure (and admire) the people who acknowledge us."

You never know when someone will need extra support from you. Be available.

Where to Start This Week

You don't need to overhaul your calendar. Start here:

  • Schedule a one-on-one with each team member you don't know well.

  • Ask for their life story, and be ready to share yours.

  • Ask about their goals and where they want to be in five years.

  • Greet each person by name every day for a week.

  • Ask for feedback on how you're doing, once trust is there.

If your team doesn't trust you yet, that's not a verdict on you. It's a sign the account is low. Start making deposits today.

Trust is built one conversation at a time. Start with the next one.

Who on your team do you need to get to know better?

Heads up: This post is adapted from my book From Supervisor to Super Leader with the help of AI, but thoroughly reviewed and edited by me.

Get Shanda's bestselling book

Improve your team skills now. Do you want to be better at coaching staff? Do you find it hard to give honest feedback? Get this book.

Helping leaders thrive!

© 2026 Become a Super Leader - All Rights Reserved

1711 Willamette St Suite 301 #739

Eugene OR 97401